No. 10
in makeup
Buy on Amazon
Check current price
Confirm the exact version, seller, current price and stock before ordering. Catalog prices and availability are historical snapshots, not live offers.
● Affiliate link.
We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases through our links — editorial choices and discussion summaries are independent of commission rates.
How it works.
73% would recommend
Why we ranked it No. 10 in makeup
Sample
59 redditors with explicit opinion · 25 positive · 7 negative · 2 neutral
Score0.747 — formula: 0.75 × % positive + 0.25 × pos/neg ratio
Confidence95% CI: 57–85% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence
Verdict
Recommended — ≥50% positive. Mixed but more good than bad.
Sources
r/Makeup, r/DrugstoreMUA, r/MakeupAddictionCanada, r/AsianBeautyAdvice, r/PaleMUA
Maybelline · makeup
Recommended
Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
r/Makeupr/DrugstoreMUAr/MakeupAddictionCanadar/AsianBeautyAdvicer/PaleMUA
TL;DR — Reddit consensus
A cult favorite drugstore mascara that adds length and definition without clumping. May dry out quickly in tube and cause lash breakage for some.
What redditors love
+
Adds length, definition, and volume at drugstore price
“this is probably the best afforable mascara that has truly added definition, volume and colour to my eyelashes”
u/Unusual_Loquat480 · r/DrugstoreMUA →
+
No clumps, applies cleanly with easy-to-use wand
“No clumps, easy applicator.”
u/Foxxyred13 · r/Makeup →
+
Tubing formula removes easily with just warm water
“Maybeleine Sky High is amazing tubing mascara and comes off easily with warm water”
u/OnehappyOwl44 · r/Makeup →
+
True black color, not muddy brown like some mascaras
“The color is very pretty and not like the poop brown some mascaras are.”
u/Foxxyred13 · r/Makeup →
+
Loyal repeat buyers who've tried high-end alternatives
“I've been using Maybelline sky high for YEARS. Tried others even high end but I always go back to her.”
u/Lovergirl15501 · r/Makeup →
What they don’t
−
Tube dries out quickly, shortening product lifespan
“the Maybelline mascara tube dries out SO fast”
u/Royalchariot · r/DrugstoreMUA →
−
May cause lash breakage with regular use
“I've noticed my lashes breaking, especially on my left eye there is like a whole clump missing from the corners.”
u/obertpobert · r/MakeupAddictionCanada →
−
Very wet formula can create spider lashes
“Maybelline sky high are both very wet and give me spider lashes.”
u/Mobile_Ad_9090 · r/DrugstoreMUA →
−
Doesn't hold curl, lashes drop straight after minutes
“it doesnt work like maybe 5 minutes they stay curled then boom they are straight again”
u/WhichEmploy3306 · r/AsianBeautyAdvice →
MORE PRODUCT REVIEWS
Catalog suggestions may serve different purposes. Check each product’s role and limits.
Explore another review
Essence
Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
→
Direct quotes
Archived Reddit excerpts.
Selected comments are individual experiences, not a representative poll. Follow the links for the original context.
L
u/Lovergirl15501
·
r/Makeup
I've been using Maybelline sky high for YEARS. Tried others even high end but I always go back to her.
S
u/Sensitive_Young_3920
·
r/DrugstoreMUA
Maybelline age rewind concealer & Sky High mascara are overrated
C
u/Complete_Bee4911
·
r/DrugstoreMUA
Lash Sensational Sky High mascara. These four products literally do half my makeup routine and I'm obsessed!
U
u/Unusual_Loquat480
·
r/DrugstoreMUA
this is probably the best afforable mascara that has truly added definition, volume and colour to my eyelashes
D
u/DexterCutie
·
r/Makeup
I love Maybelline Sky High mascara. It's so affordable and better than high end, imo
Show all 34 mentions ↓
"I LOVE the maybelline fireworks lash sensational mascara. Best shit I've used in YEARS. My holy grail!"
View thread →
"Maybeleine Sky High is amazing tubing mascara and comes off easily with warm water"
View thread →
"ended up going back to Sky High and Voluminous Panoramic. I like both equally"
View thread →
"the Maybelline Lash Sensational mascara has no competition at any price range"
View thread →
"I really like Maybelline Sky High, worth a try"
View thread →
"Maybelline sky high waterproof is great to lock your lashes in the same place after the eyelash curler"
View thread →
"I really like maybellines sky high mascara so I stopped buying expensive mascara"
View thread →
"the lash sensational from maybelline it doesnt work like maybe 5 minutes they stay curled then boom they are straight again"
View thread →
"Every year I ask for a normal tube of maybelline sky high mascara for christmas, that's the only mascara I use for the rest of the year"
View thread →
"Cheekbone mascara has replaced my l'Oreal Lash Sensational mascara. The formula and the wand is amazing!"
View thread →
"For reference the Sky High Waterproof mascara works pretty well on my lashes"
View thread →
"I've noticed my lashes breaking, especially on my left eye there is like a whole clump missing from the corners."
View thread →
"Maybelline Sky High: fluttery, flexible, great for drama"
View thread →
"the Maybelline mascara tube dries out SO fast"
View thread →
"I've been using the Maybelline Lash Sensational for the past 10-ish years."
View thread →
"Maybelline sky high are both very wet and give me spider lashes. What to try next?"
View thread →
"I really like Maybelline Lash Sensational in Blackest Black because it gives my lashes a thicker/longer look without overcoating them."
View thread →
"It's only sold in June - August in the U.S., so I buy about seven at a time."
View thread →
"It looked so good on her I got some for me. It does smear a bit but after 10+ hours."
View thread →
"I personally find Maybelline Sky High to be a decent replacement. Still not as good, but it'll do I guess."
View thread →
"was going to buy the maybaline sky high in burgundy but now that this is out idk which one i should buy"
View thread →
"Mascara: Maybelline Lash Sensational in Magenta. I did my bridal makeup myself recently and was happy with it"
View thread →
"i've been using sky high by mabaline and unfortunately both of those brand test on animals so i don't recommend"
View thread →
"Lash Sensational non waterproof comes off with plain water for me"
View thread →
"always have a tube of maybeline sky high mascara on hand when I run out of hourglass mascara"
View thread →
"maybelline lash sensational mascara, black, waterproof"
View thread →
Discussion sources
Linked Reddit conversations.
●
r/Makeup
Whats Your Holy Grail Mascara
●
r/DrugstoreMUA
Unpopular Opinions
●
r/DrugstoreMUA
My Maybelline Everyday Essentials Help Me
●
r/DrugstoreMUA
Ranking The Best Mascara
●
r/Makeup
High End Mascaras Are A Scam
●
r/Makeup
Am I The Only One Who Thinks Mascara Is Now Made
●
r/Makeup
Drugstore Makeup That Preforms Like Luxury
●
r/MakeupAddictionCanada
Lor
Read also
More guides to explore.
Adjacent
More products to compare.
02
Glossier
Cloud Paint
Compare the exact product, archived experiences and evidence limits in the full review.
★ · on Amazon
Read full review
03
wet n wild
Photo Focus Loose Setting Powder
Compare the exact product, archived experiences and evidence limits in the full review.
★ · 11.9k Amazon reviews
Read full review
04
Milani
Make It Last Setting Spray
Compare the exact product, archived experiences and evidence limits in the full review.
★ · 35.9k Amazon reviews
Read full review
Previously out of stock — verify with seller
05
URBAN DECAY
All Nighter Setting Spray
Compare the exact product, archived experiences and evidence limits in the full review.
Read full review