No. 38
in makeup
Buy on Amazon
Check current price
Confirm the exact version, seller, current price and stock before ordering. Catalog prices and availability are historical snapshots, not live offers.
● Affiliate link.
We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases through our links — editorial choices and discussion summaries are independent of commission rates.
How it works.
57% would recommend
Why we ranked it No. 38 in makeup
Sample
13 redditors with explicit opinion · 4 positive · 3 negative · 0 neutral
Score0.571 — formula: 0.75 × % positive + 0.25 × pos/neg ratio
Confidence95% CI: 25–84% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence
Verdict
Polarizing — Threshold-based label from our methodology.
Sources
r/DrugstoreMUA, r/IndianMakeupAddicts, r/MakeupRehab
Maybelline · makeup
Polarizing
Instant Age Rewind Eraser
r/DrugstoreMUAr/IndianMakeupAddictsr/MakeupRehab
TL;DR — Reddit consensus
A drugstore under-eye concealer that doesn't crease and needs minimal product. Struggles with darker circles and humid weather.
Amazon vs Reddit
Amazon loves it. Reddit isn't sold.
On Amazon: ★4.4 from 240,884 reviews — that's roughly 85% positive.
On Reddit: 57% of 13 redditors recommend it.
The gap of 27 points is unusual and worth reading the cons before you buy.
What redditors love
+
Doesn't crease and feels hydrating under eyes
“Does not crease and is hydrating.”
u/chai_lie · r/MakeupAddictionCanada →
+
Only need one small dot per eye
“I only need 1 small dot worth per eye & I really love it.”
u/MotherAd4477 · r/DrugstoreMUA →
+
Reliable enough to return to after trying others
“After trying a few other under eye concealers I've returned to the Maybelline Age Rewind-the icon.”
u/thinkingmagic · r/DrugstoreMUA →
What they don’t
−
Doesn't cover dark circles, can turn area grey
“it didn't cover my dark under eyes and it turned that area more grey than anything, it was a disappointment to put it mildly”
u/Rozzays · r/DrugstoreMUA →
−
Separates and runs off in humid weather or sweat
“the staying power is pretty bad. It holds up terribly in humid weather. If I sweat at all, it would separate and run off”
u/Parapurp · r/DrugstoreMUA →
−
Sponge applicator leaves tiny fibers on face
“this applicator was leaving tiny invisible fibers all over my face… here's an extra reason to rip it off and throw it away”
u/No-Establishment6529 · r/MakeupAddiction →
−
Formula doesn't last beyond 4 months in bottle
“despite ensuring you get a clean inside bottle, mine didn't even make it 4 months”
u/unique_plastique · r/MakeupAddiction →
MORE PRODUCT REVIEWS
Catalog suggestions may serve different purposes. Check each product’s role and limits.
Explore another review
Nars
Radiant Creamy Concealer
→
Direct quotes
Archived Reddit excerpts.
Selected comments are individual experiences, not a representative poll. Follow the links for the original context.
T
u/thinkingmagic
·
r/DrugstoreMUA
ork makeup. After trying a few other under eye concealers I’ve returned to the Maybelline Age Rewind-the icon.
P
u/Parapurp
·
r/DrugstoreMUA
ll, it would separate and run off my face and leave runny lines lmao. Now I use maybelline instant age rewind for a similar thin consistency but much better coverage and durability.
Z
u/ZucchiniNervous9204
·
r/IndianMakeupAddicts
e I use the L’Oréal infallible serum foundation in the shade 4-5 Medium and the Maybelline age rewind concealer in the shade R130. Both of them match me perfectly as I use concealer
N
u/nsj95
·
r/DrugstoreMUA
The L'Oreal concealer is one of my faves! I usually go between that one and the Maybelline Age Rewind.. depends what's on sale when I need to re-up
M
u/mayitree
·
r/IndianMakeupAddicts
ion but really wants to know which one should go for ...
Some says on dry skin maybelline age rewind conceler dont last .
Nd SB ,Mars dont go well for my face ( got pigmentation b
G
u/gnocchi902
·
r/MakeupRehab
it because it got gross.* I'm currently going through a similar thing with the Maybelline Age Rewind concealer
4. Gisou lip oil: I bought this the second it dropped on Sephora, be
Discussion sources
Linked Reddit conversations.
●
r/DrugstoreMUA
Daily Makeup
●
r/DrugstoreMUA
r/DrugstoreMUA
●
r/IndianMakeupAddicts
What Products Can I Use To Achieve This Look
●
r/DrugstoreMUA
r/DrugstoreMUA
●
r/IndianMakeupAddicts
Hows These Concealer
●
r/MakeupRehab
Things Ive Decluttered In 2025 What I Learned
●
r/DrugstoreMUA
r/DrugstoreMUA
Read also
More guides to explore.
Adjacent
More products to compare.
02
Glossier
Cloud Paint
Compare the exact product, archived experiences and evidence limits in the full review.
★ · on Amazon
Read full review
03
wet n wild
Photo Focus Loose Setting Powder
Compare the exact product, archived experiences and evidence limits in the full review.
★ · 11.9k Amazon reviews
Read full review
04
Milani
Make It Last Setting Spray
Compare the exact product, archived experiences and evidence limits in the full review.
★ · 35.9k Amazon reviews
Read full review
Previously out of stock — verify with seller
05
URBAN DECAY
All Nighter Setting Spray
Compare the exact product, archived experiences and evidence limits in the full review.
Read full review