No. 23 in makeup

// glowrecs.com/maybelline-fit-me-poreless

Compare alternatives → Choose by need → Browse makeup →

Confirm the exact version, seller, current price and stock before ordering. Catalog prices and availability are historical snapshots, not live offers.

● Affiliate link. We may earn a commission on qualifying purchases through our links — editorial choices and discussion summaries are independent of commission rates. How it works.

63% would recommend

48 redditors · 17 threads · 9 subs
95% CI: 41–81%
★4.5 on Amazon (154,461 reviews)

63%

37%

Positive 12 Neutral 0 Negative 7

Why we ranked it No. 23 in makeup

Sample 48 redditors with explicit opinion · 12 positive · 7 negative · 0 neutral

Score0.632 — formula: 0.75 × % positive + 0.25 × pos/neg ratio

Confidence95% CI: 41–81% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence

Verdict Mixed — Threshold-based label from our methodology.

Sources r/Makeup, r/DrugstoreMUA, r/PaleMUA, r/AsianBeauty, r/IndianMakeupAddicts + 4 more

Maybelline · makeup

Mixed

Fit Me Poreless

Name: Fit Me Poreless
Brand: Maybelline
Rating: 4.5 (154461 reviews)

r/Makeupr/DrugstoreMUAr/PaleMUAr/AsianBeautyr/IndianMakeupAddictsr/MakeupAddiction

redditors mentioned this 19 opinions rated · 63% positive · 17 threads · 9 subreddits incl. r/Makeup, r/DrugstoreMUA, r/PaleMUA Reddit data: 2023–2026 · how we collected this →

TL;DR — Reddit consensus

Drugstore foundation with loyal fans for concealer and matte finish, but oxidizes badly on many skin tones and shade matching is inconsistent.

What redditors love

Concealer version has cult following among longtime users

“You can pry the Maybelline fit me concealers from my cold, dead fingers.”

u/Ckelle06

Matte + Poreless works well with oily skin control

“ever since I started this combo, I no longer get stressed about greasy”

u/pyracies

Creates smooth finish that gets compliments on skin texture

“I've had compliments on my face looking so smooth with it before! and the maybelline fit me concealer!”

u/DotSelect4245

Better color range for tan to deeper skin tones

“I use Maybelline Fit Me most of the time; sometimes switching it up with L'Oréal's Infallible. If I rea”

u/CMYG9695

What they don’t

−

Matte + Poreless formula oxidizes badly on multiple users

“I see I'm not the only one who's been burned by maybelline fit me matte + poreless 💀”

u/thehikinggal

−

Shade matching inconsistent even within same line

“these are 2 shades from Maybelline fit me. one feels lighter and one feels darker. Also it oxidised badly.”

u/Impossible-Clerk-262

−

Dewy version too glossy for some skin types

“I used to use Maybelline Fit Me foundation but found it was too "dewy."”

u/ChristineBorus

−

Price jumped from $5-7 to $15-17 in recent years

“I use to buy the Maybelline fit me foundation for 6-7$ pre covid, I saw it at shoppers the other day for $17.”

u/SherlockMarvelHP

MORE PRODUCT REVIEWS

Catalog suggestions may serve different purposes. Check each product’s role and limits.

Explore another review

Wet n Wild

Photo Focus Dewy Foundation

· 100% · 22u

→

Explore another review

TIRTIR

Mask Fit Red Cushion

· Evidence limitations

→

Read all 48 mentions on Reddit ↓

Direct quotes

Archived Reddit excerpts.

Selected comments are individual experiences, not a representative poll. Follow the links for the original context.

u/Ckelle06 · r/Makeup

You can pry the Maybelline fit me concealers from my cold, dead fingers.

View thread →

u/Ok_Habit6837 · r/PaleMUA

y 49 years on earth. I hated most of them. I present to you my new holy grail - Maybelline Fit Me in Pink and Mauve. Just the right amount of color without looking like a sunbur

View thread →

u/docinthemaking222 · r/DrugstoreMUA

uch that it gets me overwhelmed! Also , side note i have recently rediscovered Maybelline fit me dewy and smooth and i have not been this happy with a base for years! I convin

View thread →

u/Impossible-Clerk-262 · r/IndianMakeupAddicts

Shade match? So these are 2 shades from Maybelline fit me. one feels lighter and one feels darker. Also it oxidised badly. Does anybody h

View thread →

u/fuzzycici · r/MakeupAddiction

so cute and perfect for my skintone! What do we think :) Products - Face: \- Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless foundation shade 310 sun beige \- E.L.F. Hydrating Camo Concealer in light san

View thread →

u/thehikinggal · r/DrugstoreMUA

did not oxidize at all. EDIT: I see I’m not the only one who’s been burned by maybelline fit me matte + poreless 💀

View thread →

Show all 19 mentions ↓

u/peewee_ · r/Makeup

"love to hear what works for you because if I get another recommendation to try Maybelline Fit Me, L’Oréal True Match, Nars Soft Matte, Haus Labs or anything else that only last"

View thread →

u/DotSelect4245 · r/DrugstoreMUA

"erum, I've had compliments on my face looking so smooth with it before! and the maybelline fit me concealer!"

View thread →

u/Missable_Syrup_07 · r/IndianSkincareAddicts

"was on my 2nd tube when I realized I looked darker than usual (My shade is 115 maybelline fit me). During my vacation, I went home from hostel and asked my mom if she noticed"

View thread →

u/floralscentedbreeze · r/Makeup

"How long does it take for you to use up your makeup? The maybelline fit me pressed compact took me almost 1.5 years to use up. I don't know how people use"

View thread →

u/pyracies · r/AsianBeauty

"for me personally. Also, it's possible it just works well with my foundation (maybelline fit me matte) - ever since I started this combo, I no longer get stressed about greasy"

View thread →

u/CMYG9695 · r/AsianBeauty

"ations work better for me mostly because the color range (I’m quite tan). I use Maybelline Fit Me most of the time; sometimes switching it up with L’Oréal’s Infallible. If I rea"

View thread →

u/StrawberryKiss2559 · r/Makeup

"Shout out to Maybelline Fit Me foundation. I used to wear MAC but couldn’t get it for a minute so I tried the"

View thread →

u/Chateaudelait · r/Makeup

"Loreal pretty much owns them all- Color Match foundation or Maybelline Fit Me."

View thread →

u/SherlockMarvelHP · r/MakeupAddictionCanada

"Omg yes, I use to buy the Maybelline fit me foundation for 6-7$ pre covid, I saw it at shoppers the other day for $17. Insa"

View thread →

u/Ok_Entrepreneur_6938 · r/Sephora

"eauty (matte) foundation. For concealers I have to stick with Fenty (matte) and Maybelline Fit Me for my face but can use the more moisturizing ones under my eyes only. There ar"

View thread →

u/Lower_Jicama5727 · r/Makeup

"ed, however most elf products now are at least $7+. There isn’t any reason that Maybelline Fit Me went up from $5 to $15 in less than 10 years aside from it becoming trendy onli"

View thread →

Discussion sources